Trump's aggressive approach towards Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles isn't annihilating them. Instead, it's driving a transformation within these practices.

Trump's aggressive approach towards Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles isn't annihilating them. Instead, it's driving a transformation within these practices.

The environmental, social, and governance (ESG) movement has experienced significant shifts in the United States and Southeast Asia, influenced by both political changes and market forces.

**United States: A Shift in Labels, Enduring Principles**

Under the Trump administration, the ESG movement became politicized, leading many businesses and investors to distance themselves from the term. However, the underlying principles of ESG have remained essential to financial practices.

The deregulation by the administration increased investor exposure, prompting a response in the form of strengthened internal governance controls. This shift has brought governance into sharper focus, as investors prioritize board oversight and governance standards.

Despite the change in terminology, the core principles of ESG remain integral to investment strategies. The focus on governance has intensified, indicating that while the political climate may influence labels, the substance of responsible investment practices endures.

**Southeast Asia: Market-Driven Sustainability**

In contrast, Southeast Asia's evolution of ESG practices is driven more by market forces and regional dynamics than by political changes in the U.S. Private capital firms in the region have been driving the growth of sustainable practices, focusing on human rights, climate resilience, and social license.

Southeast Asia's carbon market faces political uncertainty and methodological setbacks, hindering the harmonization of carbon standards and the development of a robust domestic market. This challenges the effective implementation of ESG practices related to carbon trading and environmental sustainability.

**Comparative Analysis**

| **Aspect** | **United States** | **Southeast Asia** | |-------------|-----------------|-------------------| | **Political Influence** | ESG politicization has led to a shift in terminology and focus on governance. | Market-driven sustainability is more prevalent, with less reliance on U.S. political changes. | | **Market Response** | Investors have strengthened governance controls. | Private capital firms are driving sustainable practices, focusing on human rights and climate resilience. | | **Challenges** | Deregulation has increased investor exposure. | Political uncertainty and methodological setbacks hinder carbon market development. |

**A Continuing Trend**

Over the past decade, US ESG funds have attracted more than $130 billion in inflows, while total fund assets reached $344 billion by the end of 2024. Investors continue to align capital with those who employ the strategy, regardless of what it is called (ESG, responsible investing, sustainability, or resilience).

The political backlash refocused the market, triggering a shift but not a retreat. Private capital, including private equity, venture capital, and infrastructure general partners, are leading the next evolution of responsible investment. Despite the change in lexicon, the fundamentals of ESG as a financial practice are forging ahead.

Business leaders and investors recognize the need to meet new challenges from a risk prevention and opportunity creation perspective to generate the greatest opportunities for returns on investment. As Aron Cramer, CEO of sustainability consultancy BSR, suggests, ESG won't vanish but will mature and be called something else.

1. The focus on governance in ESG practices remains crucial for financial strategies, even as the political climate may influence the terminology used in the United States.
2. In Southeast Asia, the growth of sustainable businesses is driven primarily by market forces, with private capital firms promoting human rights, climate resilience, and social license.
3. Corporate responsibility and sustainability continue to be significant factors in the investment world, as evidenced by the billions of dollars flowing into ESG funds in the United States.
4. The education-and-self-development sector can play a vital role in fostering an understanding of ESG principles, empowering individuals to make informed decisions when it comes to investing and adopting sustainable lifestyles.
5. As Aron Cramer of sustainability consultancy BSR suggests, the ESG movement may mature and transform, but its core principles of addressing climate change, promoting sustainable business practices, and ensuring corporate responsibility will persist.

Read also: